Overshadowing Assessment
Overshadowing is the effect a new building has on sunlight reaching the gardens, courtyards, parks and open spaces around it. It is a planning matter, assessed under the BRE guidelines, and it is separate from the daylight and sunlight tests applied to windows. A scheme can pass every window test and still be refused because it puts a neighbour’s garden into shade.
Blue Sky Surveyors prepare overshadowing assessments for planning applications and for neighbours objecting to them across London and the South East.
What an overshadowing assessment measures
The test comes from BRE 209, Site Layout Planning for Daylight and Sunlight (2022). For a garden or other amenity area to be considered adequately sunlit, at least half of its area should receive at least two hours of direct sunlight on 21 March, the spring equinox.
The guideline is not met where, after the development, less than half the space receives two hours of sun on 21 March and the area that does is less than 0.8 times its existing value. Both limbs have to apply. A garden that keeps more than half its area in sun for two hours still meets the guideline even if it has lost more than a fifth. The same test is applied to the scheme’s own gardens and communal spaces, so a development can fail on the amenity it provides to its own residents as well as on the effect it has on neighbours.
The 21 March date is deliberate. It is halfway between the winter and summer extremes, so it gives a fair picture of a typical day. A garden that gets two hours of sun on 21 March will get considerably more in summer.
How we carry it out
We build a 3D model of the existing site, the surrounding buildings and the proposed scheme, then run a sun path analysis for 21 March. The output is a plan of each affected space, shaded to show where the two hour threshold is met before and after the development, with the areas and ratios set out in a table.
Where a council has asked for more, we add transient shadow plots. These show the shadow cast by the scheme at hourly intervals on 21 March, 21 June and 21 December, so the planning officer can see when during the day each space is affected and for how long.
The assessment is usually delivered as part of a full daylight and sunlight report, but we can prepare it on its own where the windows are not in question.
When you need one
Councils ask for an overshadowing assessment whenever a scheme is tall enough or close enough to affect neighbouring gardens, and routinely for:
- New residential blocks next to houses with rear gardens
- Extensions that step out alongside a neighbour’s garden
- Schemes next to parks, playgrounds, allotments or school grounds
- Any development providing communal amenity space of its own
Many London boroughs now set out their requirements in a validation checklist. If the checklist says daylight, sunlight and overshadowing, you need all three.
Overshadowing and objections
If you are a neighbour and a scheme will put your garden into shade, the overshadowing test is the one to use. The daylight and sunlight tests only cover windows, and a scheme that leaves your rooms adequately lit can still take most of the afternoon sun from your garden.
We prepare overshadowing reports for objectors. The report takes the same approach as the applicant’s assessment, so the planning officer can compare like with like, and it sets out where the scheme does not meet the BRE recommendations. Where the applicant’s report has used a favourable baseline or left out a space, we say so.
Read more about daylight and sunlight for neighbours.
What the results mean
The BRE guidelines are guidance, not rules. A council can approve a scheme that does not meet them, and it often will in a dense urban setting where every garden is already partly in shade. What the assessment does is put the effect in numbers, so the officer can weigh it against the benefits of the scheme and so the decision can be defended if it is appealed.
A scheme that comfortably meets the two hour test for every neighbouring garden is unlikely to be refused on overshadowing. A scheme that halves the sunlit area of a neighbour’s garden will need a good reason.
Frequently asked questions
Is overshadowing the same as loss of sunlight to windows?
No. Sunlight to windows is tested using annual probable sunlight hours (APSH) on the window itself. Overshadowing tests sunlight on the ground across a whole space. They are separate tests and a scheme is assessed against both.
Does a right to light cover my garden?
No. A right to light protects light through windows into rooms. There is no legal right to sunlight in a garden. Overshadowing is a planning consideration only, which is why it matters to raise it during the planning application rather than afterwards.
What about balconies and roof terraces?
The guide lists gardens, parks, playgrounds and sitting out areas. The two hour test is commonly applied to roof terraces and larger balconies as amenity space too, though councils give them less weight than ground level gardens.
Can an overshadowing assessment be done after planning?
It can be done at any stage, but it only has weight while the application is live or at appeal. Once permission is granted the planning question is closed.
How much does an overshadowing assessment cost?
It depends on how many spaces are affected and whether it is part of a full daylight and sunlight report. Ask for a quote and we will come back with a fee.
Our Latest Reviews
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Excellent service as quoted and delivered on time - would defo recommend and use again!Posted on Google![]()
Hamza YusufTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We reached out to Blue Sky Surveyors to help us potentially with a Right of Light question related to a planning application. Stevan came back quickly and provided an initial and very helpful assessment of the implications free of charge. While his assessment meant that we did not require Blue Sky’s services this time, based on our experience we will make sure to use them when we do require their services.Posted on Google![]()
SolveigTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I was recommended to get in touch with Stevan for day light / sun light assessment (via friends who also got some work in the past) - needed this report & findings to add to my planning permission. I was very satisfied with his quotation. The final report was both professional and supportive. Working with Stevan and Blue Sky was a pleasure and I am more than happy to recommend him and his team. Thank you.Posted on Google![]()
Vik SureshTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Professional service with a quick turnaround - Thank you, will definitely use BSS again!Posted on Google![]()
Can YavuzTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I used Blue sky surveyors and was really impressed with the service I received, they were very professional efficient and provided me with a highly detailed report , I could not have asked for more. If you are thinking of using their services then I would highly recommend them.Posted on Google![]()
Andy cappTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Great customer service, quick in delivering and advise given was direct and clearPosted on Google![]()
Sharon ChaggarTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Referred to Stevan by a local SW London surveyor regarding a right to light ‘issue’. We needed an independent view on a light survey for planning conducted by our neighbours. Stevan interpreted the report for us, putting a legal ‘case’ / question to bed without cost to us. Very helpful and professional.Posted on Google![]()
Simon DasTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We engaged with Stevan Dillon of Blue Sky Surveyors with regards to a Right of Light matter regarding a development that was being constructed opposite our office in central London and we are very glad that we did. We found them extremely professional and helpful, guiding us every step of the way through a situation that we had very little knowledge of They were always contactable an responded swiftly to any queries that we may have had. which brought the matter to a swift and happy conclusion We would have no hesitation is recommending their services to anyone looking for an expert in this fieldPosted on Google![]()
Blou BoyTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I called Blue Sky Surveyors in a last minute and urgent survey. Steven talked me through why and what was required based on an e-mail I read to him from my neighbour. Following this, they were extremely accommodating with the timing of the site visit. Flawless communication and efficient. Highly recommended!Posted on Google![]()
Nimesh RadiaTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Excellent service, very professional , I would highly recommend Blue sky to anyone making a right of light claim... John James Director Templar London LtdPosted on Google![]()
john james